• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Sally Starr’s Pizza

At Sally Starr’s Pizza, our story is rooted in a passion for authentic flavors and community. Located in Atco, NJ, we pride ourselves on delivering a warm, inviting atmosphere where families and friends gather. Our menu features a delectable range of pizzas, appetizers, and Greek specialties, ensuring there's something for everyone. From our crispy mozzarella sticks to our flavorful chicken souvlaki, each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and care. With options for takeout and delivery, alongside outdoor seating and kid-friendly amenities, Sally Starr’s Pizza is your go-to spot for a satisfying meal that brings people together.

Sally Starr’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Maria Grossman
Maria Grossman

My husband and I love this place! Very friendly woman at the counter, delicious food. He had an Italian hoagie and I had an egg sandwich. Well definitely be back!

Marlena Carlis Waer
Marlena Carlis Waer

I originally meant to post this review in December, but you know how crazy December can be. The first time we called for delivery, it was the Friday after the new menus were delivered in the mail and it was pouring rain. The lady who ...

Makayla Rodriguez
Makayla Rodriguez

absolutely delicious food, pretty long wait time but its understandable with all the new business and theyre still adjusting . my fiance and i have been eating there every night past couple nights in a row and i must say its delicious all ...

Maggie M
Maggie M

We cant get enough of this place, the pizza is perfect. I know no one likes to live in shadows of previous businesses but we gave this place another try after they went under new ownership. We were not fans of Sallys originally. So happy ...

Alex Keister
Alex Keister

We orders a few pizzas and 50 wings. We didnt receive the correct amount of wings however after speaking with Mo he made sure we were delivered more wings than we initially ordered and apologized. ...

Elaine Gee
Elaine Gee

How hard is it to make a chicken cheese steak wrap? Apparently, this place cant make one. Ive tried twice. Not going to be a 3rd time. Its even on their menu. First time I got some breaded chicken with lettuce tomato and onions with ...

Diane
Diane

We Went out to breakfast there this morning. I have to say the food was fast and yummy and the prices are more resonable then most places .The young man Sam who took care of us was very nice and right on point.. ...

John Wessell
John Wessell

Took the entire family to breakfast Sunday including those visiting for the holidays thats 12 people at once. All the food came out hot, at the same time, and everyone said their meal was very good. ...

Location

Welcome to the culinary adventure that is Sally Starr’s Pizza, a gem nestled in Atco, New Jersey. This unclaimed pizza paradise offers an array of delectable dishes that cater to every palate—from mouthwatering pizzas to hearty breakfast omelettes. With its inviting setting, Sally Starr's is perfect for families, groups, or anyone craving a delicious meal in a lively atmosphere.

Location: Conveniently situated at 439 Jackson Rd, Atco, NJ 08004, Sally Starr’s Pizza is easily accessible and offers a host of utilities designed to enhance your dining experience:

  • Delivery and Takeout
  • Reservations Accepted
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Alcohol Service
  • Good for Kids and Groups
  • Bike Parking Available
  • Moderate Noise Level
  • Catering Options
  • Television for Entertainment

One of the standout features of Sally Starr’s Pizza is its extensive breakfast menu, which includes a variety of omelettes. Each dish is crafted meticulously to ensure a burst of flavor with every bite. Signature selections such as the:

  • Greek Omelette: A delightful mix of onions, peppers, tomatoes, and feta cheese.
  • Florentine Omelette: Packed with fresh spinach and creamy feta.
  • Meat Lovers Omelette: A carnivore's delight with bacon, ham, and sausage.

For those seeking an authentic taste experience, the Original Tarantini Panzarotti is not to be missed. With options ranging from classic cheese to the heartier chicken and steak varieties, this dish encapsulates a beloved comfort food that excites the taste buds.

As you take in the flavors and atmosphere, you'll notice a casual yet convivial vibe where laughter and chatter fill the air. The staff at Sally Starr's Pizza creates an approachable and friendly environment, making it easy to linger over your meal and enjoy quality time with friends and family.

In summary, Sally Starr’s Pizza is more than just a place to grab a bite. It’s a community hub where delicious food, great service, and a warm ambiance come together. Whether you're in the mood for a quick pizza pick-up, a leisurely breakfast, or a night out with friends, this establishment is ready to serve up happiness on a plate.

Visit them today or call (856) 768-1114 to place your order. Dive into the delightful experience at Sally Starr’s Pizza—where every meal feels like a celebration!